Comparative statements: three quotations, one fair table
Enter what each supplier quoted for each item. The lowest rate is marked, the totals are worked out, and the payment terms and delivery days sit underneath, so the choice is made on more than price.
Now onboarding companies in Dhaka.
Supply Chain / 2. Comparative Statements
Comparative statement
| Item | Gulf Petrochem FZErecommended | Bengal Plastics | Polymer Corp BD |
|---|---|---|---|
| PP granules15,000 kg | 118 | 124 | 121 |
| White masterbatch2,000 kg | 210 | 205 | 215 |
| Black masterbatch3,000 kg | 198 | 202 | 195 |
| Total | BDT 27,84,000 | BDT 28,76,000 | BDT 28,30,000 |
| Payment terms | 60 days LC | 30 days | 45 days |
| Delivery | 25 days | 10 days | 14 days |
Recommended supplier
Gulf Petrochem FZE
Lowest total, and within the credit terms the company can accept. Delivery in 25 days fits the production plan.
Approve and raise orderSend for tender
A comparison, in three reads
Read the table down for price, across for terms, and then at the bottom for the decision.
- 01Rates
Item by item
For each item, the quoted rate from each supplier. The lowest is marked in green.
- 02Totals
Worked out for you
Quantity times rate, added up for each supplier, so the total decides, not one item.
- 03Terms
Beyond price
Payment terms and delivery days sit under the totals, and the decision records why one supplier was chosen.
What the statement holds
- Suppliers
- One column for each, with the name at the top.
- Items and quantities
- One row for each, with the quantity from the requisition.
- Totals
- The sum for each supplier.
- Payment terms and delivery
- Such as 60 days LC and 25 days.
- Decision
- The recommended supplier, with the reason, and the next step: raise the order or send it for tender.
A comparison sits between the need and the order
It starts from an approved requisition and ends as an order, or as a tender if the choice is too big.
Before the comparison
After the comparison
Comparisons for the way Bangladeshi buyers negotiate
The cheapest quotation is not always the best. Credit days, delivery time and the letter of credit all change what a rate really means.
Price per item and in total
Both are shown, so one cheap item does not hide an expensive order.
Credit and delivery beside it
Sixty days’ credit can be worth more than a lower rate.
Local and foreign together
A Dhaka trader and an overseas supplier sit in one table.
A reason on file
The recommendation is written, for the auditor and the owner.
One comparison, from quotations to decision
A sample raw material comparison, the way it usually runs.
Three suppliers send their quotations for PP and masterbatch.
The rates are entered, and the totals come to 27,84,000, 28,76,000 and 28,30,000 taka.
Gulf Petrochem is lowest, with 60 days’ credit.
The recommendation is written and approved.
The order is raised to the chosen supplier.
How different trades use comparative statements
- Retail
Comparing stock suppliers by rate and credit.
- Food & Hospitality
Comparing produce and supply quotations.
- Real Estate
Comparing material and contractor quotations.
- Consulting
Comparing software and equipment quotations.
- Manufacturing
Comparing raw material by rate, credit and lead time.
- Health & Fitness
Comparing equipment quotations.
- Trades
Comparing parts suppliers.
- Others
Comparing quotations for programme purchases.
Questions we get about comparative statements
What is a comparative statement?
A table that puts quotations from several suppliers side by side.
How is the best supplier chosen?
By the total, and by the terms: payment days and delivery.
What does the green mark mean?
It marks the lowest rate for that item.
Can I record why a supplier was chosen?
Yes. The recommendation carries the reason.
What happens after approval?
You can raise the order, or send the purchase for tender.
Where is Adon ERP available?
We are currently onboarding companies in Dhaka. Book a demo and we will walk through a sample purchase with you.
Bring three real quotations. We will compare them in the demo.
A live demo in English or Bangla, using sample books close to your own trade, with time for your accountant’s questions.